treat yourself with love.

SHOP

Quick View
Christmas Pack
$32.00
Add To Cart
Quick View
Hanukkah Pack
$32.00
Add To Cart
Quick View
Snow Cap
from $24.00
Add To Cart
Quick View
Build Your Own Pack
$32.00
Add To Cart
Quick View
Seasonal Pack
$32.00
Add To Cart
Quick View
Classics Pack
$32.00
Add To Cart
Quick View
The Sampler Pack
$36.00
Add To Cart
Quick View
Confetti
from $24.00
View Options
Quick View
Chocolate Pretzel Chunk
from $24.00
ADD TO CART
Quick View
Brown Butter Oatmeal [GF]
from $24.00
View Options
Quick View
Brown Butter Snickerdoodle
from $24.00
ADD TO CART
Quick View
White Chocolate Mint Chip
from $24.00
Add To Cart
Quick View
Ginger Molasses
from $24.00
Add To Cart
Quick View
Sufganiyot [Jelly Donut] (df)
from $24.00
Add To Cart

Interested in custom orders or flavors? Contact us and we’ll see what we can do!

Spreading the love.

“With Love cookies are both comforting (in their careful and tender flavors) and surprising (in their ability to make familiar flavors suddenly new and thrilling). A perfect treat for special occasions or for regular pleasures!”

— Olivia, Highland Park

“The cookies were absolutely delicious and so easy to make. You can tell the batter is handmade from scratch, not from a machine. They didn’t last very long in my freezer- I couldn’t stop eating them!?

— Samantha, Glencoe

“With Love cookies instantly transport me to a cozy fall day, cuddled under a flannel blanket, sipping on a steaming drink, orange leaves against a blue-grey sky. Their warmth and deliciousness fill my soul. If I could, I would live inside these cookies.”

— Katie, Chicago